Late Once Again- NXT TakeOver: New Orleans & WrestleMania 34 Reviews
I finally got to sit down and watch both shows in their entirety. The perspective you get when you’re there is so different from watching it on the network, obviously, but there’s always the possibility that when you’re sitting there live, you won’t get the full picture. I wouldn’t have wanted to experience those shows any other way though….two (three really, because I went to RAW too) really really great nights of professional wrestling and I cannot thank WWE enough for giving me another weekend to remember forever.
NXT Takeover
Match #1: Dain vs Cole vs EC3 vs Ricochet vs Sullivan vs Dream
Welp, this was an absolute car wreck of a match and I loved every second of it. Everyone involved looked absolutely fantastic, especially Ricochet, who took more crap then anyone I’ve ever seen in a ladder match not named Dolph Ziggler, but I REALLY loved the Sullivan/Dain dynamic throughout the whole thing. They went back to face off against each other multiple times, AND tried to outdo each other with those ladder spots on the outside. Even Dream, who looked VERY nervous, showcased himself well, and even with his mishaps, was still over as hell. Cole winning was a safe choice, but with Aleister being the biggest babyface ever right now, a heel champion can’t be too bad.
Match #2: Bayzler vs Moon
I wrote in my predictions that I wanted the format of this match to be different from their last TakeOver encounter and that is EXACTLY what I got. Ember looked as if she had found a way to avoid Bayzler’s ground-based offense and really did well in focusing on Shayna’s arm this time around. Shayna jamming her arm back into its socket (allegedly) by ramming it into the post then proceeding to lock Ember in the submission almost out of thin air was spectacular stuff, and even though the “babyface fights hard but passes out” thing is overdone in NXT women’s matches, Shayna looked strong as hell coming out of that.
Not a fan of Ember moving directly to RAW from that, but clearly NXT is going to try and breed the next class of girls in as quickly as they can.
Match #3: Dunne and Strong vs Authors of Pain vs Cole and O’Reilly
I’m a really huge fan of everyone involved here and I love the style and pace that they always work. Cole was essentially a non-factor, taking a double Chokeslam through a table early on from AOP, but the rest of the match was unpredictable, hard-hitting and very smooth. Kyle O’Reilly has stamina for DAYS being able to hold his own in there alone for 95% of it, but I was surprised we didn’t see more of Pete Dunne, who also tends to work long, in there.
Ultimately, it took a few seconds for the live crowd to realize “Oh my god, Strong just turned heel”, but when they did, the place lit up. Strong has needed something to reinvigorate his character since his failed attempt in War Games, so this gives him new life. He looked so happy with the reaction he got, as he should be.
Match #4: Black vs Almas
I actually liked this match a lot more watching it back on the network then I did in person. Andrade does a lot of little things that you don’t see when you’re halfway across the arena, so it’s nice to be able to go back and watch it at your leisure.
Zelina Vega’s repeated attempts at helping Andrade score the win, and the desperation she showed when each attempt failed, was a small but beautiful way to show how much of a threat Aleister is. He doesn’t need much help these days as his in-ring work is clearly the best its been in his NXT tenure, but she does absolute wonders for him. I will say, one thing that did translate in an arena setting was the striking. Both guys make it look so effortless, both giving and receiving, and, though it was brutal, it was a joy to watch.
Vega ultimately being the reason why Andrade lost the title, now that I think about it, probably wasn’t a smart move if they were going to just keep them together, but the crowd popped so hard for it so I can’t complain about a moment like that.
Match #5: Gargano vs Ciampa
Ciampa walking out with no music and taking in all the heat in the world….absolutely brilliant.
I gotta say….it had been a long few days for me and the time 10 p.m rolled around that night I was pretty shot, but the near 40 minutes of this match gave me my second or third wind. I worship the Michaels/Jericho Unsanctioned match, but these two went out there and told a completely different story in a completely different manner. The two of them, at this moment in time, are so far apart on the spectrum of heat vs insurmountable love from the fans, but were both so ruthless and daring on that night. The powerbomb spot from the apron to the exposed floor is something I will never ever forget, nor will some of those shots from the crutch, which sounded like a whip off Ciampa’s body.
I was not a fan of the knee brace causing Ciampa to tap at the end….I personally did not think it looked that painful. Had Gargano repeatedly bashed Ciampa with it then forced him to tap to the Gargano escape, then I would have gotten behind it, but they still went with it and the crowd lost their minds so what do I know?
WrestleMania 34
Preshow
Match #1: Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal
These matches are so hard to watch live cause there’s no commentary telling you who is in it, who got eliminated and so on and so forth. Only when the ring clears out a bit does it get easier.
Ziggler stood out among the pack, as he usually does, and even though it benefits absolutely no one, maybe one day he’ll win one of these things. Speaking of winners, no one asked for a Corbin/Kane face off. Like, nobody wanted that.
Having Matt Hardy in there in the end with Corbin and Rawley was a dead giveaway and it was at that moment that I knew Rusev would not be winning later on that night. Bray Wyatt coming in with the assist was a nice touch, and I’m currently loving the two of them teaming together, even if I always have preferred Bray as a heel.
Match #2: Alexander vs Ali
This was such a good match up until the finish. Like, how do you have Alexander get his foot on the rope to evade a pinfall after taking Ali’s insane reverse splash finish, but then not have Ali do the same after taking the Lumbar Check? Yes, it leaves no doubt that there’s a definitive winner but it just didn’t sit well with me.
Which is a shame because for the entire match the two of them just performed at the highest caliber and looked like they were doing it with ease. Both guys are so young and so hungry and so naturally gifted that it just makes sense for them to be in that spot on the biggest card of the year together.
Match #3: WM Women’s Battle Royal
Really happy that the NXT girls got to showcase themselves and stake their claim in that moment. They should be proud of themselves.
The match itself was nowhere near as good or unpredictable as their Rumble was….I mean, how could it be? Becky Lynch being dumped out kind of early and Sarah Logan lasting WAY too long put a bad taste in my mouth, as did the finish. Sasha and Bayley could have very easily have had a one-on-one match on the card (maybe it’s better they didn’t after watching that AWFUL match they had on RAW), so I thought, “Ok, maybe they’ll get 5-7 minutes in the match by themselves.” Instead, they build up all that steam just to have Bayley eliminate Sasha WAY too quickly, then lose to Naomi, who I did not consider once the whole match.
Why couldn’t someone like Ruby Riot have gotten the win? All three of the final girls in there have had Mania moments….both Naomi and Bayley had one just last year, so why can’t we elevate new talent?
Main Card
Match #1: Balor vs Rollins vs Miz
How fitting was it that the three workhorses of the company open the show together, setting the bar? I was hoping for a little more though, especially after how good the Finn/Seth match from RAW the week before was.
The finish seemed a bit off-kilter….visually it just didn’t look very pretty, both in person on TV. And Seth really didn’t need the win, so I was put off. Finn’s “all-inclusive” thing is a really nice touch, and he’s the only one of the three who hasn’t had a Mania moment yet so I would have really liked to have seen him with his hand raised.
Match #2: Charlotte vs Asuka
The placement of this match on the card was insulting before it even started, but even more so after seeing the finish.
The finish, like the last match, just felt off to me. I know Charlotte had been working on Asuka’s leg for some of the match, but she hit a Spear, took a really long time to do anything, tried to get her in the Figure-Eight while Asuka fought back, then just locked her in it with one arm and that was that. Very strange.
Other then that, these two delivered. I actually felt like performed more on a Mania level then any other pairing on the card, so props to them.
Match #3: Mahal vs Roode vs Rusev vs Orton
This was very middle-of-the-road. I KNEW that WWE would troll the fans and have Rusev eat the pin here and that’s exactly what happened. He looked great throughout though, really absorbing the energy the fans were giving him, unlike Roode, whose first Mania match was a forgettable one. What a shame. Hopefully RAW does much better by him.
And now Jeff Hardy is champion. Wrestling is weird sometimes.
Match #4: Rousey and Angle vs Triple H and Steph
Best match on the card, by far. I fully admit that I underestimated Ronda….I think we all did, but my god did she deliver. They all did.
Ronda played the role of the fearless newcomer who would do anything to prove herself, even squaring up against Triple H with no fear. Angle, who looked much better then he did at Survivor Series, was merely an accomplice, but still played an integral role. Triple H and Steph sold it all to PERFECTION, starting the match off as the reigning overlords, confident that this “outsider” wouldn’t be able to hang, then slowly but surely, fear and outright astonishment creeped in, knowing that they were not going to be able to put Ronda down easy.
Much of Ronda’s offense was MMA based, but as she continues to learn and grow, she’ll hopefully transition into a more wrestling-based style. Her submissions fit in perfectly, but I’d like to see her adapt just a little more. But I mean, hats off to her man. She killed it.
Match #5: Bludgeon Brothers vs Usos vs New Day
I was really bummed that the TLC stipulation didn’t come to fruition, and while both the Usos and New Day did look good, they were just completely overshadowed. This was a glorified Smackdown match that was put in the WORST spot after the clinic Rousey and Co. put on just minutes prior. I had no doubt the Bludgeon Brothers would get the win, but both Usos and New Day have worked too hard the last few years to be shafted like that.
Match #6: Undertaker vs Cena
The presentation of this was absolutely brilliant.
There was a small part of me, and I’m sure a lot of others as well, that genuinely thought it wasn’t going to happen after Cena’s bit with Elias. However, that made the feeling that rushed through my body….that adrenaline, that fire, so much more intense when that gong went off and Taker did his ominous walk down to the ring. It’s mesmerizing every time and I am so grateful to have seen it in person as much as I have.
He looked mobile, he looked agile….he looked great. Could he have kept at that pace for 10-12 minutes? I don’t think so, but it was just so great to see him moving like that again. Three minutes was exactly what we needed this time around if next year they’re going to go for a Career vs Career stip.
Thank you Taker. You made me feel alive.
Match #7: Bryan and Shane vs Owens and Zayn
It didn’t hit me until Bryan was out in the ring in his gear that he was actually wrestling again. What an incredible moment.
Owens and Zayn took him out on the outside early on, then honed in on Shane. Even though Bryan most likely won’t want to be “protected”, it was a smart move. The whole thing was just building up to when he would finally get back in the ring and take both of them out on his own, and when he did, the place came unglued. He looked to be in FANTASTIC shape and looked to be very comfortable in there, so here’s to many more years for him.
And now this whole thing meant nothing, because Owens and Zayn moved to RAW with no consequences. Again, wrestling is weird.
Match #8: Jax vs Bliss
This match really convinced me that while Nia has gotten better, as shown in her work with Asuka and in the buildup to this match, she has a lot more work to do. She looked impressive as she always does in some spots, but sluggish and sloppy in others. Alexa tried to work on a limb and chop Nia down, playing the role of the vicious heel, but then when she realized what she was up against, the fear that immediately crossed her face was nothing short of brilliant. I’m happy for Nia, I just hope she learns to adapt. And quickly.
Match #9: Nakamura vs Styles
This match felt like a big deal. From the overhype of the “dream match” scenario to literal rock star entrance for Shinsuke, it felt like something big was coming. Was it up to par with what they did in Japan a few years ago? No, but was it still a great match? Absolutely.
It had been reported that AJ was dealing with some injury in the weeks leading up to Mania, which scared me because Shinsuke’s style isn’t exactly subtle and could easily aggravate any injury or make it worse. I feel like because of that, there was a bit of trepidation from both guys, and also knowing that they couldn’t just blow it out of the water if they were going to have to stretch out this feud for a few more months.
I was a bit surprised that it ended after one Styles Clash, but the post match antics were fantastic and I loved how they presented it. Does having both Asuka and Shinsuke lose make the Rumble look pointless? I could care less about that, I just worry more about how it screams loud and clear that the New Japan stigma is still lurking for both of them.
Match #10: Strowman and Nicholas vs Cesaro and Sheamus
Alright….I know I’m the minority here but I HATED this. I couldn’t even focus on the match because I was so annoyed that they could have done something really monumental with this and all we got was a scared little kid that was good for meme culture for a few days.
They’re not even DOING anything with Strowman right now so they could have made a new monster tag-team and it would have been great for a few months. Hell, Rey Mysterio was apparently in talks to work Cena and that didn’t happen so what the hell was he doing?? Like, who was REALLY happy with this outcome?
Match #11: Lesnar vs Reigns
I’m not gonna say this match was atrocious, but it wasn’t anything special. I flew my ass from New York for this thing so if you think for one second that I was going to check out of it and start throwing a beach ball around, you’re crazy, but that doesn’t mean either of those guys earned the right to have been in the main event.
Brock totally kicked his ass again, which is fine, but SIX F5’s??? That was overkill. Not even blood could save this match, as all the fans saw was something we’ve seen Brock do already and once Reigns got up and started doing what he does like he’s not currently profusely bleeding from his head, it didn’t even matter. Brock winning was shocking….I mean, who REALLY thought he was sticking around? But still, a sour end to a decent show. Nakamura/Styles would have been a much better main event choice.